It forces me to question their bias on the subject. Implicit within the term cpd is the notion that teaching is a profession. Different frameworks vary in outlook and imply contrasting attitudes and values. Teaching the most important profession it appears, therefore, that of all secular professions, teaching is the most profoundly important of all these professions teaching is the worse paid.
The status of teaching as a profession scholarlycommons. Access to education, outcomes and teaching processes the study indicated that where teaching workforces are feminised, access rates at the primary level are generally good. Paper argues that the title question is a debate that has distracted teachers from their actual working conditions and is based on a sociological models of profession that were abandoned in sociology in the late 1970s but perpetuated in education literature for another 20 years. Teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom. Teaching, according to oriahi 2006, is the programmed development of the child in a classroom setting by someone who has undergone the prerequisite training and is ascribed with the full. Teachers pedagogical knowledge and the teaching profession 2 p a g e rationale and policy context the imperative in recent years about improving student outcomes is also about improving the quality of the teaching workforce. Both terms are synonymous with each other but i find two qualifying words that make teaching a vocation. In real lifeyes, the thing we are living right nowthe idea that four years of college, with any major, is sufficient. What do we gain by trying to decide if teaching really qualifies as a profession.
Teaching profession in nigeria have been handed a lot of criticisms, maybe it is a profession or not. It has the potential to have a great impact in the molding of the next generation. Teaching is definitely a profession because without getting higher. These criticisms have been making needed changes difficult and often incur resentment. Teaching is a profession where misery does more than just love company it recruits, seduces, and romances it. Aug 11, 2017 teaching is a profession where misery does more than just love company it recruits, seduces, and romances it. For the last 50 years educators have devoted a great deal of energy to the debate over whether teaching can be considered a profession.
What are the characteristics of teaching profession. The state of the teaching profession before starting my debate research, i made a cluster graphic organizer to see which characteristics correlated with the topic, the state of the teaching profession. Theories of learning and teaching what do they mean for. In recent years, however, recruiting and retaining quality teachers has. It is the teaching profession, which helps an individual for his growth fully, in his body, mind, spirit, intellectual emotion and with moral values and artistic sensitivity. We need to redesign how we recruit, select and educate the profession as we prepare for our future of learning. That is why education should be valued by social institutions like government, the church, the family and civil society. We often use the term profession in a generic sort of way referring to what is your tradevocation. Michael goves announcement that qualified teacher status will no longer be required to teach in academy schools will do nothing to. This study focuses on teaching professionalism with special reference to its feminisation debate. Benchmarks for learning and teaching benchmarks for learning knowledge teaching moving from passive absorption of information individual activity individual differences among students seen as problems what. Ballantine and spade list six characteristics that distinguish a profession from other occupations. Foundations of education and instructional assessment.
Tariqul islam textbook pedagogy the teacher, educational leadership. Discuss michael goves announcement that qualified teacher status will no longer be required to teach in academy schools will do nothing to reassure people that he has. Dedication to purpose, knowledge expertise and advocacy are core strengths of those in the teaching profession. Teaching as a profession viewpoint of the bangladeshi secondary school teachers farhana rashid md. Why teaching is not a profession and how it might become. Teacher professionalization and teacher commitment. Exploring the feminisation debate fatimah kelleher ed. Whether teachers qualify as profes sionals is one of these debates. Teaching as a profession is not only limited to teaching in universities institutions. This was done in order to make room for training on how to structure teaching.
Teaching is also not for those who just randomly decided on it one day or chose it as a last resort. A fourth reason that teaching is not a profession is the salary structure. That is, we do not seek to provide a historical account of the sources behind teachers status, nor do we seek to assess the benefits and. Teaching as a profession characteristics of a profession. Teachers do not see clients, take appointments, put a sign on their doors, hand out a shingle, or even cancel classes due to an emergency. Considered to be more than profession, teachers are regarded as the strongest pillar of the society. In trying to break down the debate about teaching as a profession, we must first look at the concept of profession.
The ongoing debate whether teachers are professionals or just laborers in a large educationindustrial complex has long been rooted in the policies that drive the educational system. Teaching professionalism and the feminisation debate in pakistan. Profession is derived from the word profiteor meaning to profess. Therefore, teaching has been accepted as the noblest profession. Smes are experts in a particular discipline and hold a masters or even higher degree qualification in their area of specialization. The statement that sets me off is usually some variation of,teaching isnt really a profession. It is the power, prestige and value that society confers upon a profession that more clearly defines it. A teacher is like a potter who delicately shapes our impressionable minds and mold it into a vessel that defines our perception and ambitions.
A third reason teaching is not a profession, is the white coat test. In the next chapter i intend to discuss this new view. Is teaching a profession, an occupation, a calling, or a. Teaching is a vocation a calling randall butisinghs. This blog will look at the important factors to support teaching as a research led profession. By now i hope i have convinced you that this is a trick question, and that teachers must not allow themselves to get tricked again. Issues have ranged from the reasons why the teaching profession became genderimbalanced in favour of women in certain countries in the first place, to what the impact of this might have on learning processes and educational outcomes. Im also confident about the future of the teaching profession because, in so. It is for those who make the deliberate decision to answer the call to become an educator, a mentor, a friend. Collins evaluate the criteria of professionalization as they. Saying that teachers are professional does not make them. The debate surrounding women, the teaching profession and feminisation is wideranging.
While there are those who see teaching as just a job, there are those who recognise that it is something more. Teaching will be a quasiprofession since it will have some characteristics of a profession, but will have them to a lesser extent than the paradigm cases of professions. Teaching is as critical, many might suggest even more so, as any profession including medical, law or accountancy to list a few. Teaching is a profession that is a mother of all other occupations. The words worthy and great fulfilment breaks the borderline whether teaching is. Unfortunately, this turns out to have been the wrong question, and so led us to the wrong sort of answers. It is stressful and taxing, not for the faint of heart. Originating from the latin, professio, profession originally meant the declaration of belief in or acceptance of religion or a faith usually related to religious beliefs. Overview the objective of this resource is to provide an introduction to debate that will allow you to use debate in the classroom.
Oxford english dictionary 2012 supports this by stating that. Critics of teaching profession have said, teaching lacks the germane characteristics of a viable profession. Some of the characteristics of professions seem to fit teaching fairly well. Call it an occupation or profession, teaching has elements of a calling in the sense of called to serve. Teaching is the one profession that creates all other professions and education is the most powerful weapon which we can use to change the world then these clearly suggest that teaching at all levels is a scholarly profession. Whether youre a veteran teacher or just embarking on your teaching career, here are 20 reminders why you have the most important job in the world as an educator. Mar 27, 2020 considered to be more than profession, teachers are regarded as the strongest pillar of the society. Work hard or work at crossword puzzles, a teacher will be paid the same amount. Teachers guide to introducing debate in the classroom newfoundl and and labrador page 2 of 29 pages newfoundl and and labrador introduction t o debate. This chapter attempts to theoretically and empirically ground the debate over the status of teaching as a profession.
There are no scripted plans left for a substitute on the assembly line. Teaching, a profession or a vocation herald express. No other profession, except perhaps parenting, wields such influence on the formation of minds as teachers do. Its been an argument or a debate for some time whether teaching is in fact a profession or not. Professionalism and professional development of teachers is an important discussion to unpack perspectives as to its definition in order to understand the entry points of professionalism and its feminisation arguments.
Teaching the most important profession education council. Feb 03, 2017 this blog will look at the important factors to support teaching as a research led profession. Teaching is a profession, not a job the student life. For examples of recent discussions of teaching as a profession, see. Teaching is not just a profession, not an easy paycheck. Future of teaching profession index of education international. Status and prestige high social status professions enjoy a high social status, regard and esteem conferred upon them by society. The state of the teaching profession essay 4 words. For the last 70 years, educators have devoted a great deal of energy to the debate over whether teaching can be considered a profession. Women and the teaching profession commonwealth bookshop. Teaching is not a lost art profession, but the regard for it is a lost tradition.
The debates on women and teaching have been wide ranging and, in some cases, contentious. Higher social function this high esteem arises primarily from the higher social function of their work, which is regarded as vital to society as a whole and thus of. Essay on the teaching profession 1654 words bartleby. The state of the teaching profession essay 1281 words 6 pages.
Many people consider teaching as a profession while others consider it as a vocation. Which one we adopt impacts on what and how we teach. In a profession, there are fines if a person messes up, or does not perform. Pdf profession is the phenomenon of vital activity created by division of labor that social, economical and technological factors require. There is hardly a policy debate in the fields of general and special education that does not question whether teaching is a true profession or whether it is something less, such as a skilled occupation. According to websters dictionary, a profession is defined as a calling requiring specialized knowledge and often long and intensive academic preparation.
It is a vocation, a calling the teacher is the most important person in any civilization, as on him depends the molding of the nation. Why teaching is the most important profession published on july 20, 2015 july 20. The teaching profession has average prestige and social standing when compared to other professions. Debates on the policy directions in education in the past. In these teachercentered teaching methods, students do not participate actively in the learning process. A profession arises when any trade or occupation transforms itself through the development of formal qualifications based upon education, apprenticeship, and examinations, the emergence of regulatory bodies with powers to admit and discipline members, and some degree of monopoly rights. This contributes to teaching being seen more as a convenient occupation for women rather than a challenging profession for both sexes. While, unfortunately, it is not perceived in this great country to be on an equal footing as those professions named above teachers are instrumental in preparing others for those professions. This edited book, published as a collaboration between the commonwealth secretariat and unesco, represents an important contribution to scholarship on women and the teaching profession, and indeed to the wider field of gender and education. Debate learning method and its implications for the formal. Avoid people who are unhappy and disgruntled about the possibilities for. Another factor, as maya menon of the teacher foundation, bangalore, points out, is that teaching is a highly genderbiased profession biased towards women who are traditionally seen as homemakers. Teachers have the capacity to shape the minds and futures of many. In the game of lifeyes, the board gameteaching is one of the few jobs that you can draw only if you went to college, suggesting the job requires some amount of proper training and higher education.
As in most debates on professions and on professionalism the characteristics. Thankfully, its also a profession thats filled with rewards that outweigh the trials. Teaching is a paid occupation, therefore i believe should be defined as a profession. As teaching profession is not only an occupation but has a great. Josephs college, university of alberta, edmonton underneath teaching there lies a conceptual framework through which we view its role and purpose. Furthermore, we do not make any warranty with regards to reliability and accuracy of the information.
1394 656 794 592 840 843 26 219 141 40 1352 160 2 1460 139 510 544 1493 1108 1501 1006 947 1093 248 1234 28 1408 1040 1374 1028 146 777 1412 675 1091 1053 646 1469 46 871 456 87